Featured

Net Investment Income Tax: Double Taxation is Allowed in Appeals Court Ruling

by Susan Maine-Descamp, US Tax & Banking Chair

As Americans abroad, we often have worries of double taxation. In general, the US tax system and the many bi-national treaties that the US has entered into are intended to prevent double-taxation through credits, exclusions, and sourcing rules. However, on August 31, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued companion opinions related to the Foreign Tax Credit and Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) that reversed previous taxpayer wins and officially allowed for double-taxation of Americans residing outside the US.

Origin of the Net Investment Income Tax

As with most things, the NIIT was passed with the best of intentions. It was first enacted as part of the funding bill of the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010. The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) was going to provide more healthcare to more Americans, but US laws are supposed to be revenue neutral and thus this tax was included to generate revenue. In the officially drafted law, the Net Investment Income Tax is called the “Unearned Income Medicare Contribution”. Since this is titled as a Medicare Contribution, it was not put in the tax code under Chapter 1 “normal taxes and surtaxes” section, nor even in Chapter 2 “self-employment” but in a new, separate chapter 2A. Strangely, Chapter 2A is after Chapter 2, not within it. If the NIIT had been in chapter 2, double taxation would have been mostly prevented because Chapter 2 taxes are already specifically exempted for many countries through Social Security Totalization Agreements. But instead, it is in Chapter 2A, code section 1411, and the question of foreign tax credits or exclusion of taxation for Americans abroad has been an issue ever since the tax began being collected. It came into effect in tax year 2013, at which time the IRS created form 8960 and titled the form the Net Investment Income Tax, the “Medicare” terminology was dropped. Despite the name and the original intentions of the drafters, the NIIT collected does not go into the Medicare Trust fund, instead it flows into the Treasury General Fund like any other normal income tax, there is no explanation for this so it may have been an oversight or error.

How Much is the Net Investment Income Tax?

The Net Investment Income Tax is a 3.8% tax on worldwide investment income of US citizens and tax residents once their Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) exceeds the threshold based on their filing status ($125,000 for single and married-filing-separately, $200,000 for head-of-household, and $250,000 for married-filing-jointly and qualifying surviving spouse). It should be noted, the income levels that subject a taxpayer to the NIIT are not inflation adjusted from the amounts in the original 2010 law. Thus, the $125,000 per filer threshold still applicable in 2025 would correspond to about $83,500 back in 2010. This tax, while seemingly small and applicable to only the very wealthy, will apply to more and more taxpayers as inflation increases.

For Americans residing outside the US, because the NIIT is codified in chapter 2A, the Foreign Tax Credit cannot be claimed against it because the Foreign Tax Credit is specifically applicable only to Chapter 1 taxes in the code. And further, because the NIIT is calculated using the MAGI, the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (form 2555) is added back to net income to determine if one is subject to the NIIT. It is very common for expats, particularly on foreign assignments with high relocation costs/packages, to pay Net Investment Income Tax even after paying much higher rates of income tax in the local country. Furthermore, there is no rate of local country income tax that will reduce or eliminate NIIT. Thus for Americans abroad with high income, the NIIT is a payment due to the IRS that cannot be reduced no matter how high the resident-country tax rate.

Bruyea and Christensen Court Cases

Since 2013, Americans abroad have been challenging the NIIT. Two court cases that were somewhat successful were Bruyea v United States and Christensen v United States.

Paul Bruyea was a US citizen residing in Canada who had gains on the sale of Canadian real estate which were fully taxed in Canada. When preparing his tax return, he claimed the foreign tax credit against his regular income taxes but additionally claimed it against the NIIT citing article 24 of the US-Canada Tax Treaty. The IRS denied the claim, so he paid the tax, then sued for a refund (standard procedure) and won in the Court of Federal Claims.

Matthew and Katherine Christensen, U.S. citizens residing in France, sold stock in a French company at a gain and paid French taxes. Similarly, the Christensens claimed French tax credits against the NIIT under Article 24 of the U.S.-France Treaty, the IRS disallowed the credit, the Christensens paid the tax, sued for a refund, and won in the Court of Federal Claims.

The IRS appealed both cases to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and had the cases consolidated to provide companion decisions: one decision for both cases.

Appeals Court Decision

The appeal was successful for the IRS and a loss for the taxpayers with all three appeals judges finding for the IRS. The IRS argued many technical and procedural points, but the main focus was if the treaty language allowed the foreign tax credit to be applied to the NIIT. The court found that it did not because Congress must have intentionally put the NIIT outside of Chapter 1 knowing that it would not benefit from the Foreign Tax Credit. The IRS also argued that the treaty language, while intending to prevent double-taxation (which is part of the full title of the treaties), is not so expansive as to override US internal law. And finally, the IRS mentioned that allowing US citizens residing abroad to claim the Foreign Tax Credit against the NIIT while US citizens resident in the US would not be able to would result in "anomalous results” that would treat Americans abroad better than those living in the US.

NIIT for Americans Abroad Going Forward

There are plans to appeal this decision. Unfortunately, the next place up in the appeals process is the Supreme Court and they don't take many cases. Tax lawyers are also working on other test cases to bring to the court and argue other legal strategies, so there is hope. But the legal system is slow and these kinds of cases take many years to get to court and get decided and go through all appeals, so we should not expect a different definitive answer anytime soon.

Explaining this decision, the tax, and how it applies to Americans abroad is difficult and technical because logically, the NIIT is either an income tax and should be eligible for foreign tax credits or it's a medicare/social security charge and should be exempt since Americans abroad don't get the benefits of Medicare/social programs. But the judges in the appeal have successfully argued semantics and technical rules to continue to apply this tax against common sense.

All US citizens should be aware that if they have high income or a large investment gain during a particular tax year, they could be liable for this additional 3.8% on interest, dividends, capital gains, and rentals to the US regardless of where the income is sourced or how much they pay in tax to their resident country.

Sources:

Foreign Tax Credits Against the Net Investment Income Tax: A Critical Analysis of the Federal Circuit’s Decisive Rulings in Bruyea and Christensen by Ed Zollars, CPA

Cornell Law School, Internal Revenue Code Section 1411

IRS about form 8960

Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010

Bipartisan Policy Center

Share This Content

Visit Our Partners